NONFICTION MINUTE
  • HOME
  • The Nonfiction Minute
    • Minutes to Browse
    • by Subject
      • English/Language Arts
      • Social Studies
      • STEM
      • Art
      • FCS/ Nutrition
      • Health & Wellness
      • Music
      • Research Skills
  • For Teachers
    • Transfer to Teaching
    • T2T Tutorial
  • AOC/Authors on Call
  • End-of-Year Giving
  • Print Collection
  • Teacher Input
  • HOME
  • The Nonfiction Minute
    • Minutes to Browse
    • by Subject
      • English/Language Arts
      • Social Studies
      • STEM
      • Art
      • FCS/ Nutrition
      • Health & Wellness
      • Music
      • Research Skills
  • For Teachers
    • Transfer to Teaching
    • T2T Tutorial
  • AOC/Authors on Call
  • End-of-Year Giving
  • Print Collection
  • Teacher Input

The Flaw in the Seedless Banana

12/21/2017

2 Comments

 
Picture
Dorothy Hinshaw Patent
Nature’s Animal Ambassador

Picture
PictureYou can see how little fruit is inside a wild banana.
     You probably eat bananas at least once a week—they are the most popular of all fruits, even surpassing the apple.  But have you ever noticed that bananas have no seeds?  Probably not.  You just peel them and enjoy their soft, seedless flesh without even thinking about seeds.
    
     If you’d been strolling through a tropical forest in New Guinea thousands of years ago and reached up to pluck a wild banana snack, you wouldn’t have wanted to eat it.  The banana ancestors had big hard seeds surrounded by a small amount of sweet flesh, not worth peeling.  Sometimes, however, plants appeared with fruit that had no seeds.  Over time, people cherished these seedless fruits and grew the plants for their own use.

    
     The banana plant sends up a central stalk surrounded by very large leaves, then flowers at the tip.  The flowers produce a heavy load of bananas without being pollinated.  Then the stalk dies.  Meanwhile, the stalk sends out side shoots that become new plants.  That’s a form of cloning, meaning that all of a banana plant’s progeny are genetically identical, both to their parent and to one another.

    
     The ancestors of the modern banana could reproduce in the usual way, so  their seeds contained mixtures of DNA from the mother plant and DNA from another plant’s pollen.  This “sexual reproduction” allows for the genes of the plants to be combined in new ways.  If a disease came along, it might kill most of the plants, but some others could have natural resistance and survive.

    
     Because it lacks seeds, the banana has gotten into trouble.  Back in the 1950s, an especially sweet and tasty variety called the Gros Michel was the commercial banana.  But a devastating fungus came along and killed the plants and contaminated the soil.  Growers then chose another variety, Cavendish, which resisted the disease.  But now a wilt called Panama disease has shown up that kills the Cavendish plants.  And because bananas lack genetic diversity and because they don’t develop seeds that mix up their genes, the Cavendish has no way of defending itself.  

​     Banana growers are doing what they can to stop the spread of the disease, however, and up to now they have been successful.  But don’t be surprised if in a few years the bananas you buy look and taste different.  Luckily, there are other varieties out there, like small “finger” bananas and larger red-skinned fruits, that you can already buy in places like Hawaii.

Picture
These bananas are ready for harvest.
Picture
The banana flower cluster is huge. You can see the bananas beginning to form in the upper right of the photo.
Picture
Here are just a few kinds of bananas, from left to right—plantains, which are starchy rather than sweet; red bananas; finger bananas; and Cavendish bananas

Picture
Dorothy Hinshaw Patent's new nonfiction picture book about horses has a fresh focus: how people over the ages have decorated horses in special ways. Organized into three categories—warfare and hunting, performance and competition, performance, and ceremony—the book introduces horses such as the chariot-pulling war horse of the Persians to the rose-decorated winner of the Kentucky Derby. For more information, click here.

Dorothy Hinshaw Patent is a member of iNK's Authors on Call and is available for classroom programs through Field Trip Zoom,  a terrific technology that requires only a computer, wifi, and a webcam.  Click here to find out more.

MLA 8 Citation
Patent, Dorothy Hinshaw. "The Flaw in the Seedless Banana." Nonfiction Minute, iNK Think Tank, 21 Dec. 2017, www.nonfictionminute.org/ the-nonfiction-minute/The-Flaw-in-the-Seedless-Banana. Accessed 21 Dec. 2017.
Picture
2 Comments
Ava
12/18/2017 12:16:19 pm

I think that this is a very odd investigation. But at the same time cool because I never knew that a fruit could have no seeds. Aren't the seeds what make it a fruit?

Reply
Dorothy Patent link
12/19/2017 11:20:23 pm

Thanks for you question, Ava, You are right about fruit--in nature, a fruit is the way a plant gets an animal to spread its seeds around. But people usually don't enjoy the seeds, so they try to breed varieties that don't have seeds, then grow new plants from the parent plant in other ways. Think of it--there are tangerines without seeds, for example. New trees are made from cuttings of young branches that can grow roots. Strawberries grow runners that make new plants. So bananas aren't the only plants that people can grow with no seeds.


Reply



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    We give 'em reading that gets 'em talking!

    Learn from many voices....
    Scroll down for new
    posts.

    NEW!
    For Vicki Cobb's BLOG (nonfiction book reviews, info on education, more), click here: Vicki's Blog
    *NEWSFLASH *
    The NCSS-CBC Notable Social Studies Committee is pleased to inform you
    that
    30 People Who Changed the World has been selected for Notable Social Studies Trade Books for Young People 2018, a cooperative project of the National Council for the Social Studies (NCSS) & the Children’s Book Council

    Categories

    All
    Abolitionists
    Adams Janus
    Adaptation
    Adaptations
    Adkins Jan
    Advertising
    Aerodynamics
    Africa
    African American History
    African Americans
    Africa West
    Agriculture
    Aircraft
    Air Travel
    Ala.
    Albee Sarah
    Alchemy
    Alligators
    Allusion
    Amphibians
    Amundsen Roald
    Anatomy
    Ancient
    Ancient Cultures
    Anderson Marian 1897-1993
    Animal Behavior
    Animal Experimentation
    Animals
    Animation
    Antarctica
    Apache Indians
    April Fool's Day
    Architecture
    Argument
    Arithmetic
    Art
    Art Deco
    Artists
    Astronomy
    Athletes
    Atomic Theory
    Authors
    Autobiography
    Automobiles
    Awards
    Bacteria
    Battuta Ibn
    Bears
    Beatles
    Beavers
    Bees
    Biodegradation
    Biography
    Biology
    Biomes
    Birds
    Black Death
    Blindness
    Blizzards
    Bonaparte Napoleon
    Botany
    Bridges
    Buffaloes
    Building Materials
    Butterflies
    Caesar
    Caesar Julius
    Calculus
    Calendars
    Cannibal
    Capitals
    Caravaggio
    Carbon Dioxide
    Carnivores
    Carson Mary Kay
    Cartoons & Comics
    Carving (Decorative Arts)
    Castles
    Cathedrals
    Cats
    Caves
    Celts
    Chemistry
    Children's Authors
    China
    Choctaw Indians
    Christmas
    Chronometers
    Ciphers
    Circle
    Citizenship
    Civil Rights
    Civil Rights Movements
    Civil War US
    Civil War US
    Civil War - US
    Climate
    Climate Change
    Clocks And Watches
    Clouds
    Cobb Vicki
    COBOL (Computer Language)
    Code And Cipher Stories
    Collard III Sneed B.
    Collectors And Collecting
    Commerce
    Communication
    Competition
    Compilers
    Composers
    Computers
    Congressional Gold Medal
    Consitution
    Constitution
    Constitutional Amendments
    Contests
    Contraltos
    Coolidge Calvin
    Cooling
    Corms
    Crocodiles
    Cryptography
    Culture
    Darwin Charles
    Declaration Of Independence
    Decomposition
    De Medici Catherine
    Design
    Dickens Charles
    Disasters
    Discrimination
    Diseases
    Disney Walt
    Dogs
    Dollar
    Douglass Frederick 1818-1895
    Dr.
    Droughts
    Earth
    Earthquakes
    Ebola Virus Disease
    Ecology
    Economics
    Ecosystem
    Egypt
    Eiffel Gustave 1832-1923
    Eiffel Tower
    Einstein Albert
    Elephants
    Elk
    Emancipation Proclamation
    Endangered Species
    Energy
    Engineering
    England
    English/Language Arts
    Environmental Protection
    Environmental Science
    Erie Canal
    Etymology
    Europe
    European History
    Evolution
    Experiments
    Explorers
    Explosions
    Exports
    Extinction
    Extinction (Biology)
    Eye
    Fairs
    Fawkes Guy
    Federal Government
    Film
    Fires
    Flight
    Floods
    Flowers
    Food
    Food Chains
    Food Preservation
    Food Supply
    Football
    Force And Energy
    Forensic Science And Medicine
    Fort Cornelia
    Fossils
    Foundlings
    France
    Franco-Prussian War
    Freedom
    Freedom Of Speech
    French Revolution
    Friction
    Frogs
    Frontier And Pioneer Life
    Frozen Foods
    Fugitive Slaves
    Fulton Robert
    Galapagos Islands
    Galleys
    Game Theory
    Gaudi Antoni 1852-1926
    Gender
    Generals
    Genetics
    Geography
    Geometry
    Ghosts
    Glaciers
    Glaucoma
    Gliders (Aeronautics)
    Global Warming
    Gods & Goddesses
    Government
    Grant Ulysses S
    Grasshoppers
    Gravity
    Great Britain
    Great Depression
    Greece
    Greek Letters
    Greenberg Jan
    Habeas Corpus
    Hair
    Halloween
    Handel George Frederic
    Harness Cheryl
    Harrison John 1693-1776
    Health & Wellness
    Hearst William Randolph
    Henry IV King Of England
    Herbivores
    History
    History 19th Century
    History France
    History - France
    History World
    Hoaxes
    Holidays
    Hollihan Kerrie Logan
    Homestead Law
    Hopper Grace
    Horses
    Hot Air Balloons
    Housing
    Huguenots
    Hurricanes
    Ice
    Illustration
    Imagery
    Imhotep
    Imperialism
    Indian Code Talkers
    Indonesia
    Industrialization
    Industrial Revolution
    Influenza
    Influenza Epidemic 1918-1919
    Inquisition
    Insects
    Insulation
    Intelligence
    Interstate-commerce
    Interviewing
    Inventions
    Irrational Numbers
    Irrigation
    Islands
    Jackson-andrew
    Jazz
    Jefferson Thomas
    Jefferson-thomas
    Jemison-mae
    Jet Stream
    Johnson-lyndon-b
    Johnson-lyndon-b
    Jokes
    Journalism
    Keeling Charles D
    Kennedy-john-f
    Kenya
    Kidnapping
    King-martin-luther-jr-19291968
    King-martin-luther-jr-1929-1968
    Kings-and-rulers
    Kings-queens
    Labor Policy
    Lafayette Marie Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert Du Motier Marquis De 17571834
    Languages-and-culture
    Law-enforcement
    Levers
    Levinson-cynthia
    Lewis And Clark Expedition (1804-1806)
    Liberty
    Lift (Aerodynamics)
    Light
    Lindbergh Charles
    Liszt Franz
    Literary Devices
    Literature
    Lizards
    Longitude
    Louis XIV King Of France
    Lunar Calendar
    Macaws
    Madison Dolley
    Madison James
    Mammals
    Marathon (Greece)
    Marine Biology
    Marines
    Marsupials
    Marx Trish
    Massachusetts Maritime Academy
    Mastodons
    Mathematics
    McClafferty Carla Killough
    McKinley William
    Measurement
    Mechanics
    Media Literacy
    Medicine
    Memoir
    Metaphor
    Mickey Mouse
    Microscopy
    Middle West
    Military
    Miners
    Mississippi
    Molasses
    Monarchy
    Monsters
    Montgomery
    Montgomery Bus Boycott 1955-1956
    Montgomery Heather L
    Monuments
    Moon
    Morse Code
    Morse Samuel
    Moss Mariss
    Motion
    Munro Roxie
    Muscle Strength
    Museums
    Music
    Muslims
    Mythology Greek
    Nanofibers
    Nanotechnology
    Nathan Amy
    National Football League
    Native Americans
    Native-americans
    Natural History
    Naturalists
    Nautical Charts
    Nautical Instruments
    Navajo Indians
    Navigation
    Navy
    NCAA Football
    Nervous System
    New Deal 1933-1939
    Newman Aline
    Newton Isaac
    Nobel Prize Winners
    Nomads
    Nonfiction Narrative
    Nutrition
    Nylon
    Occupations
    Ocean
    Olympics
    Omnivores
    Optics
    Origami
    Origin
    Orphans
    Ottoman Empire
    Painters
    Painting
    Paper Airplanes
    Parks Rosa 1913-2005
    Parrots
    Passive Resistance
    Patent Dorothy Hinshaw
    Pearl Harbor
    Peer Review
    Personal Narrative
    Personification
    Pets
    Photography
    Physics
    Pi
    Pigeons
    Pilots
    Pirates
    Plague
    Plains
    Plains Indians
    Plant Breeding
    Plants
    Plastics
    Poetry
    Poisons
    Poland
    Political Parties
    Pollen
    Pollution
    Polo Marco
    Populism
    Portraits
    Predation
    Predators
    Presidential Medal Of Freedom
    Presidents
    Prey
    Prey & Predators
    Prime Meridian
    Pringle Laurence
    Prohibition
    Proteins
    Protest And Social Movements
    Protestants
    Protest Songs
    Punishment
    Pyramids
    Quarantine
    Questioning
    Radio
    Railroad
    Rainforests
    Rappaport-doreen
    Ratio
    Reading
    Realism
    Recipes
    Recycling
    Refrigerators
    Religion
    Renaissance
    Reproduction
    Reptiles
    Reservoirs
    Rheumatoid Arthritis
    Rhythm And Blues Music
    Rice
    Rivers
    Roaring Twenties
    Roosevelt Eleanor
    Roosevelt Franklin D
    Roosevelt Theodore
    Running
    Safety
    Sanitation
    Schwartz David M
    Scientific Method
    Scientists
    Scott Robert
    Sculpture
    Sculpture Gardens
    Sea Level
    Seals
    Secretaries Of State
    Segregation
    Segregation In Education
    Senses & Sensation
    September 11 Terrorist Attacks 2001
    Seuss
    Sextant
    Shackleton Ernest
    Ships
    Short Stories
    Silkworms
    Simple Machines
    Singers
    Siy Alexandra
    Slavery
    Smuggling
    Snakes
    Social Change
    Social Justice
    Social Studies
    Sod Houses
    Solar System
    Southeast Asia
    Soybean
    Space Travelers
    Spain
    Speech
    Speed
    Spiders
    Spies
    Spirituals (Songs)
    Sports
    Sports History
    Sports Science
    Squirrels
    Statue Of Liberty
    STEM
    Strategy
    Sugar
    Sumatra
    Super Bowl
    Surgery
    Swanson Jennifer
    Swinburne Stephen
    Synthetic Drugs
    Taiwan
    Tardigrada
    Tasmania
    Tasmanian Devil
    Technology
    Terrorism
    Thomas Peggy
    Thompson Laurie Ann
    Time
    Tortoises
    Transcontinental Flights
    Transportation
    Travel
    Trees
    Tundra
    Turnips
    Turtles
    Typhoons
    Underground Railroad
    US Environmental Protection Agency
    US History
    US History Revolution
    US History War Of 1812
    US Presidents
    US Supreme Court Landmark Cases
    Vaccines
    Van Gogh Vincent
    Vegetables
    Visual Literacy
    War
    Warren Andrea
    Washington D.C.
    Washington George
    Water
    Water Currents
    Wax Figures
    Weapons
    Weather
    Whiting Jim
    Wildfires
    Winds
    Windsor Castle
    Wolves
    Women Airforce Service Pilots
    Women In History
    Women In Science
    Women's Roles Through History
    Wonder
    Woodson Carter Godwin 1875-1950
    World War I
    World War II
    Wright Brothers
    Wright Orville
    Wright Wilbur
    Writing
    Writing Skills
    X-rays
    Yellowstone National Park

    Archives

    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017

The NONFICTION MINUTE is a division of iNK THINK TANK INC.
Picture
Check out our iNK THINK TANK site:
http://inkthinktank.org/

For more information or support, contact thoughts@inkthinktank.org

For Privacy Policy, go to
Privacy Policy

© COPYRIGHT 2018. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • HOME
  • The Nonfiction Minute
    • Minutes to Browse
    • by Subject
      • English/Language Arts
      • Social Studies
      • STEM
      • Art
      • FCS/ Nutrition
      • Health & Wellness
      • Music
      • Research Skills
  • For Teachers
    • Transfer to Teaching
    • T2T Tutorial
  • AOC/Authors on Call
  • End-of-Year Giving
  • Print Collection
  • Teacher Input
✕